Debt Snowball vs Debt Avalanche: Which Pays Off Debt Faster?

By 4 min read

The debt avalanche costs the least interest, because it pays off the debt with the highest interest rate first. The debt snowball pays off the smallest balance first, so your first debt disappears sooner, which keeps many people going. If you pay the same total each month, both plans usually finish at about the same time. In the example below, the avalanche saves $76.70 in interest and the snowball clears the first debt nine months earlier.

How both methods work

Both methods follow the same five steps:

  1. List every debt with its balance, interest rate (APR) and minimum payment.
  2. Decide the total you can pay each month. It must be more than the sum of the minimums.
  3. Pay the minimum on every debt, every month.
  4. Put all the extra money on one target debt.
  5. When the target is paid off, add its whole payment to the next target. The payment rolls over and grows each time.

The only difference is the order of the targets:

  • Debt snowball: smallest balance first, whatever its rate.
  • Debt avalanche: highest interest rate first, whatever its balance.

A worked example with three debts

Say you have three debts and can pay $600 a month in total:

Debt Balance APR Minimum payment
Store card $1,200 18% $40
Credit card $4,500 24% $120
Personal loan $6,000 10% $180

The minimums add up to $340, so $260 a month is left for the target debt. Interest is charged each month at the APR divided by 12, and nothing new is added to the cards.

Snowball order: store card, then credit card, then personal loan. The store card is paid off in month 5, the credit card in month 16 and the loan in month 23. Total interest: $1,778.97.

Avalanche order: credit card, then store card, then personal loan. The credit card is paid off in month 14, the store card in month 16 and the loan in month 23. Total interest: $1,702.27.

Both plans finish in month 23. The avalanche costs $76.70 less. The snowball gives you a paid-off debt in month 5 instead of month 14.

Why the difference is often small

The avalanche almost always costs the least interest, but how much it saves depends on your debts. The gap is small when the rates are close together, or when the smallest debt also has a fairly high rate, as in this example. The gap grows when your largest debt has by far the highest rate, because the snowball leaves that expensive balance until last.

So run your own numbers before you choose. If the saving is a few dollars, pick the method you are more likely to keep up. If it is hundreds or thousands, the avalanche is worth the longer wait for the first win.

Check each debt with our calculators

These free tools run in your browser, so you can test each part of your plan.

  1. See what one month of interest costs. The credit card interest calculator multiplies the balance by the APR and divides by 12. For the $4,500 card at 24%, that is $90 a month. Many card issuers work out interest daily, so your statement can differ a little.
  2. See what minimum payments alone would do. The credit card payoff calculator takes a balance, an APR and a fixed monthly payment. At $120 a month, the $4,500 card takes 71 months and costs $3,900.68 in interest. Raise the payment to $380, the minimum plus the $260 extra, and it takes 14 months with $687.56 in interest. That is the same month the avalanche plan clears it.
  3. Set a deadline. Enter a number of months in the same calculator and it shows the payment you need. To clear the $4,500 card in 12 months, you would pay $425.52 a month.
  4. Check loans too. The loan payoff time calculator gives the months needed to clear a balance at a given rate. The $6,000 loan at 10% with $180 a month takes 40 months on its own.

The debt snowball calculator and debt avalanche calculator give a quick first estimate: total debt divided by your monthly payment, rounded up, with interest left out. For the example, $11,700 at $600 a month gives 20 months. The real plans take 23 months because of interest, so treat that number as a best case.

Which one should you choose?

Choose the avalanche if:

  • your highest-rate debt is also one of the largest,
  • you are happy to wait longer for the first debt to disappear,
  • saving the most money matters more to you than quick wins.

Choose the snowball if:

  • you have a few small debts you can clear in a few months,
  • you have started payoff plans before and given up,
  • the rates on your debts are close together.

A mix works too. Clear one or two tiny balances first for a quick win, then switch to the highest rate.

Mistakes that slow down either plan

Paying only the minimums. Minimum payments are set low, so much of each payment goes on interest. In the example, the credit card alone would take almost six years at $120 a month.

Adding new debt. Both methods assume the balances only go down. New purchases on a card you are paying off push the end date back.

Spending the freed-up payment. When a debt is paid off, keep paying the same monthly total. The rollover is what makes both methods work.

Forgetting promotional rates. A 0% balance transfer usually ends after a set period. Check the date the rate goes up and plan to clear that debt before then.

Questions and answers

Is the debt avalanche always cheaper than the snowball?

When you pay the same total each month, putting the extra money on the highest rate first costs the least interest in almost every case. The saving depends on your balances and rates, and it can be very small.

How much extra should I pay each month?

Any amount above the minimums helps. Try a few payments in the credit card payoff calculator to see how the months and interest change, then pick an amount you can keep paying every month.

Do the debt snowball and avalanche calculators include interest?

No. They divide the total debt by the monthly payment and leave interest out, so they show a best case. Use the credit card payoff calculator or the loan payoff time calculator for each debt to include interest.

More from the blog